BENJY LAW CORPORATION

Judgment Creditor Resources · Part II of VI

Getting the judgment right

A judgment is a collection tool, and small drafting choices decide what it can reach. Interest, enforcement fees, stipulated judgments, and how to add an alter ego or a trustee as a judgment debtor.

6 war storiesCalifornia lawFrom War Stories from the Judgment Docket

Talk to a lawyer: (310) 203-2650

General information about California law, not legal advice. Reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship.

In this part · 6 war stories
  1. 06A $75,000 settlement could not turn into a $300,000 judgment
  2. 07Ten percent, simple, and the judge cannot add more
  3. 08The last check cleared ten days before the fee motion was filed
  4. 09Forty-seven million dollars became thirteen thousand
  5. 10A default judgment against the shell could not be stretched to its owners
  6. 11The debtor’s own LLC could be added to the judgment against him
Judgment Creditor FAQ →

The judgment is the document every later step depends on. The clerk issues the writ from it. The recorder indexes the lien from it. The sheriff levies on the name it uses. If the name is wrong, the amount is wrong, or the wrong party is on it, every step that follows inherits the mistake.

This part covers the judgment itself: how it is entered, how it grows with interest and costs, and how a court can add the person or company that really stands behind the debtor. It also covers the limits. Courts protect the people you try to add, and they will not enforce a settlement that punishes more than it compensates.

The paper

06Stipulated judgments

A $75,000 settlement could not turn into a $300,000 judgment

Vitatech Internat., Inc. v. Sporn (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 796 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A manufacturer sued a customer and its guarantor for about $166,000 in unpaid invoices. The defendants denied liability. On the eve of trial the parties settled for a single payment of $75,000. The defendants also signed a stipulation for entry of judgment “in the full prayer of the Complaint,” which the manufacturer agreed to hold unless they missed the payment date. They missed it. The manufacturer filed the stipulation and the court entered judgment for more than $300,000, including interest, attorney fees, and costs.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal ordered the judgment vacated and replaced with a judgment for $75,000 plus trial court costs. A judgment for more than four times the settlement amount bore no reasonable relationship to the harm a late payment could cause. That made it an unenforceable penalty, and a judgment built on a penalty is void and can be set aside. Calling the $75,000 a “discount” did not help, because the defendants had never admitted they owed the larger sum.

DoIf the debtor truly owes the full amount, have the debtor admit both liability and the amount in the settlement, and keep any added sum tied to real costs: interest on the unpaid balance and collection fees. Even then, expect a court to look hard at a default figure far above the settlement payment.
Don’tDon’t treat a stipulated judgment as a hammer. An oversized default number can cost you the whole stipulation.
07Interest

Ten percent, simple, and the judge cannot add more

Westbrook v. Fairchild (1992) 7 Cal.App.4th 889 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A jury awarded a plaintiff $500,000 in damages and $200,000 in punitive damages in a dispute over a contract to make a will. After an appeal, the trial court signed an amended judgment that awarded interest on both sums compounded, running until the judgment was paid. The defendant appealed the interest award.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal reversed the interest order. The Constitution and the statute set postjudgment interest at 10 percent simple interest on the unpaid principal. No statute allows compounding, and a trial court has no general equitable power to exceed the legal rate, however badly the debtor behaved. The court noted one built-in route to interest on interest: when a judgment is renewed, the accrued interest becomes part of the new principal.

DoCompute interest as simple interest on the unpaid principal from the date of entry, and keep a running ledger of every payment and cost.
Don’tDon’t compound interest in a writ, a payoff demand, or a lien. An inflated number invites a motion and undermines your credibility with the court.
08Enforcement fees

The last check cleared ten days before the fee motion was filed

Conservatorship of McQueen (2014) 59 Cal.4th 602 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A conservator won a financial elder abuse judgment. While the defendant’s appeal was pending, the conservator filed a separate lawsuit alleging she was moving real estate out of her name to avoid the judgment, and later settled it. After the appeal failed, the defendant paid the judgment and interest in installments. Her final check was honored on July 15, 2011. On July 25 the conservator filed a motion for the attorney fees spent on the appeal and on the transfer lawsuit.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court split the request. Fees for defending the judgment on appeal are not enforcement costs; they are recovered under the ordinary fee rules, so that part was timely. Fees for the transfer lawsuit were enforcement costs. A motion for those must be made before the judgment is satisfied in full. Once the final check cleared, the judgment was satisfied, whether or not anyone had signed an acknowledgment. That part came too late.

DoWhen a payoff is coming, file the memorandum of costs or fee motion first. Then accept the final payment.
Don’tDon’t quote or accept a “payment in full” figure that leaves out enforcement costs and fees you still plan to claim.

The parties

09Alter ego

Forty-seven million dollars became thirteen thousand

Greenspan v. LADT LLC (2010) 191 Cal.App.4th 486 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A developer ran his projects through several limited liability companies, moved their ownership into a trust for his children, and named his brother trustee. A seller won an $8.45 million arbitration award against two of the companies for breach of contract. The developer himself won the claims made against him personally. Around the time of the arbitration one company had taken in more than $47 million in sales. When the creditor went to collect, less than $13,000 was left. After debtor examinations, he moved to add the developer, the trustee, and two affiliated companies to the judgment. The trial court refused.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal reversed. A court may amend a judgment to add an alter ego of the judgment debtor; in theory it is naming the real defendant. The developer’s win in arbitration did not protect him, because adding him would not mean he breached the contract, only that he disregarded the companies’ separate existence. And although a trust cannot be an alter ego because it is not a legal entity, its trustee can be added. The trial court had also wrongly excluded most of the creditor’s evidence.

DoUse the debtor examination and bank subpoenas to trace where the money went, then bring the alter ego motion in the same case.
Don’tDon’t give up because the person behind the company was dismissed or won at trial on a different claim.

The debtor’s best counter: due process. The person to be added must have controlled the defense of the case, so that the person’s interests were effectively represented (Toho-Towa Co., Ltd. v. Morgan Creek Productions, Inc. (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 1096).

10Alter ego

A default judgment against the shell could not be stretched to its owners

Motores de Mexicali, S.A. v. Superior Court (1958) 51 Cal.2d 172 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A seller of used cars was paid with bank drafts that bounced. The drafts were issued under a trade name registered to a corporation, so the seller sued only the corporation and took a default judgment for $26,900.83. The corporation went bankrupt. Years later the seller asked the court to add three individuals to the judgment, alleging they ran the corporation as their alter ego and drained it.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court said no. In the earlier cases that allowed an alter ego to be added, the added party had actually controlled and paid for the defense. Here no one defended; the judgment was taken by default. Adding the individuals without letting them contest the underlying claim would deny them due process. They had no duty to step into a lawsuit that made no claim against them.

DoIf you suspect individuals stand behind an empty company, name them in the complaint, or as Does, and serve them.
Don’tDon’t take a quick default against a shell and expect to add the owners later by motion. You will likely need a new lawsuit.
11Reverse piercing

The debtor’s own LLC could be added to the judgment against him

Curci Investments, LLC v. Baldwin (2017) 14 Cal.App.5th 214 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A developer borrowed $5.5 million personally and did not repay it. The lender’s judgment came to about $7.2 million. The developer owned 99 percent of a Delaware LLC formed to hold his and his wife’s cash; she owned the other 1 percent. The LLC had distributed about $178 million to the couple in the six years before the judgment and nothing after it. It had also lent $42.6 million to family partnerships and then extended those loans five years for no consideration. A charging order against the LLC produced no money. The lender moved to add the LLC itself as a judgment debtor. The trial court held that California does not allow that.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal reversed. Reaching a company’s assets for its owner’s personal debt, called outside reverse veil piercing, is possible for an LLC on facts like these: the debtor controlled the company, no innocent member would be hurt, and the creditor’s ordinary remedy against an LLC interest had yielded nothing. The court did not decide whether the veil should be pierced. It sent the case back for the trial court to weigh the usual alter ego factors and whether the creditor had any other adequate remedy.

DoDocument what the ordinary remedies produced. An empty charging order is part of the proof.
Don’tDon’t expect this where the company has real outside owners. Protecting innocent members was central to the ruling.

FAQ

The judgment

When does interest start, and does an appeal stop it?

Interest starts when the judgment is entered and keeps running during an appeal. If the appellate court only modifies the amount, interest on the modified amount still runs from the original entry date. If the court truly reverses and a new judgment is entered, interest runs from the new date.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., § 685.020; Chodos v. Borman (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th 707.

Can we agree to a higher interest rate in a stipulated judgment?

Not once it is an enforceable judgment. A judgment entered on a stipulation has the same effect as one entered after trial, and it bears the legal judgment rate. In one case a stipulated judgment at 15 percent was cut back to the legal rate once the creditor moved to enforce it.

Law:John Siebel Assocs. v. Keele (1986) 188 Cal.App.3d 560; Code Civ. Proc., § 685.010.

What does it take to turn a settlement into a judgment?

The settlement must be made while the case is pending, either orally before the court or in a signed writing. Today a party’s attorney may sign for the party. If the case will be dismissed while payments are made, stipulate, in writing or on the record before dismissal, that the court keeps jurisdiction to enforce the settlement.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., § 664.6.

The judgment has a mistake in it. Can it be fixed?

It depends on the kind of mistake. If the paper does not match what the court actually decided (a misspelled name, a wrong figure, an omitted term), that is a clerical error and the court can correct it at any time. If the court decided the point wrongly, that is a judicial error, and the remedies are a timely post-trial motion or an appeal.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., § 473, subd. (d).

Can I add my attorney fees for collecting to the judgment?

Only if the law provides for it. The common route is a judgment that already includes attorney fees awarded under a contract. Then reasonable fees spent enforcing the judgment are recoverable as costs. That can include fees spent defeating the debtor’s separate lawsuit aimed at shrinking the judgment. A pretrial settlement offer under section 998 limits prejudgment costs; it does not limit the costs of enforcing the judgment afterward.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., § 685.040; Globalist Internet Technologies, Inc. v. Reda (2008) 167 Cal.App.4th 1267; Elmi v. Related Management Co., L.P. (2025) 108 Cal.App.5th 683.

Do I have to prove the owners acted in bad faith to add them as alter egos?

No. The test is a unity of interest and ownership between the person and the company, and an inequitable result if the company alone is treated as the debtor. One Court of Appeal reversed a trial court for reading California law too narrowly, as though it required a sham, bad faith, or intent to defraud.

Law:JPV I L.P. v. Koetting (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 172.

I sued two co-signers but only served one. Can I reach the other?

Possibly. When a judgment on a contract is entered against fewer than all of the people jointly liable, the Code of Civil Procedure allows a summons to be issued afterward requiring the unserved co-obligor to show cause why he or she should not be bound. The person can still contest liability.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., §§ 989–994.

Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.

(310) 203-2650

Statewide California.