6 short parts. Each one stands on its own and ends with a Take-Away. Every part is also on this site: read it online.
Every war story follows the same pattern: what happened, what the court decided, and what to do and not do.
War Story 01Attachment
The debtor’s cross-complaint did not stop the attachment
Lydig Construction, Inc. v. Martinez Steel Corp. (2015) 234 Cal.App.4th 937 · California Court of Appeal
What happened
A general contractor on a county jail project sued its steel subcontractor for more than $200,000. Its evidence: the subcontractor could not buy steel, could not post its bonds, and had diverted 100,000 pounds of the contractor’s steel to other jobs. The contractor asked for a writ of attachment and backed the request with business records and employee declarations. The subcontractor answered with a one-employee declaration and, on the day of the hearing, a cross-complaint claiming it was owed more than it owed.
What the court decided
The trial court attached $203,315 and the Court of Appeal affirmed. A cross-complaint reduces an attachment only if the debtor’s own claim is one that could support an attachment, and that means the debtor must show its claim is probably valid. A bare statement that the debtor “will vehemently dispute” the numbers at trial was not evidence. The contractor’s accounting records and delivery log were.
DoBuild the attachment application like a trial exhibit binder: the contract, the invoices, the ledger, and a witness with personal knowledge of each number.
Don’tDon’t assume a counterclaim kills the remedy. And don’t file a thin application; the court weighs evidence, not accusations.
War Story 06Stipulated judgments
A $75,000 settlement could not turn into a $300,000 judgment
Vitatech Internat., Inc. v. Sporn (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 796 · California Court of Appeal
What happened
A manufacturer sued a customer and its guarantor for about $166,000 in unpaid invoices. The defendants denied liability. On the eve of trial the parties settled for a single payment of $75,000. The defendants also signed a stipulation for entry of judgment “in the full prayer of the Complaint,” which the manufacturer agreed to hold unless they missed the payment date. They missed it. The manufacturer filed the stipulation and the court entered judgment for more than $300,000, including interest, attorney fees, and costs.
What the court decided
The Court of Appeal ordered the judgment vacated and replaced with a judgment for $75,000 plus trial court costs. A judgment for more than four times the settlement amount bore no reasonable relationship to the harm a late payment could cause. That made it an unenforceable penalty, and a judgment built on a penalty is void and can be set aside. Calling the $75,000 a “discount” did not help, because the defendants had never admitted they owed the larger sum.
DoIf the debtor truly owes the full amount, have the debtor admit both liability and the amount in the settlement, and keep any added sum tied to real costs: interest on the unpaid balance and collection fees. Even then, expect a court to look hard at a default figure far above the settlement payment.
Don’tDon’t treat a stipulated judgment as a hammer. An oversized default number can cost you the whole stipulation.
War Story 12Abstract of judgment
“Unknown” was not true, and the lien was void
Keele v. Reich (1985) 169 Cal.App.3d 1129 · California Court of Appeal
What happened
A creditor won a money judgment in May 1981 and recorded an abstract of judgment that October. The form asked for the debtor’s Social Security and driver’s license numbers. The creditor marked both “unknown,” although the Social Security number appeared in an exhibit to her own verified complaint. After the abstract was recorded, the debtor transferred his interest in a property to his wife in their divorce. She sued for a declaration that the lien was invalid.
What the court decided
She won on appeal. The statute said the abstract “shall” contain the number if the creditor knows it. Leaving out required information that the creditor had, or could immediately get, nullified the abstract. It did not matter that no one was actually confused about who the debtor was. The question is whether the abstract complied with the statute, and the cases that excuse minor defects all involved abstracts that contained every required item.
DoFill in every blank on the abstract from your own file: the credit application, the complaint, the deposition. Today the form calls for the last four digits of the Social Security and driver’s license numbers, if known.
Don’tDon’t write “unknown” to save time. If the information is in your file, you know it.
Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.