BENJY LAW CORPORATION

Judgment Creditor Resources · Part I of VI

Before judgment: protecting the collection

Collection starts before the judgment. How to plead claims that collect, freeze assets with an attachment or lis pendens, and undo transfers made to keep property away from you.

5 war storiesCalifornia lawFrom War Stories from the Judgment Docket

Talk to a lawyer: (310) 203-2650

General information about California law, not legal advice. Reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship.

In this part · 5 war stories
  1. 01The debtor’s cross-complaint did not stop the attachment
  2. 02The same tool worked once the property had been transferred
  3. 03The divorce papers were signed weeks after the tentative decision
  4. 04The partners’ draws were pay for work, not a fraud on the landlord
  5. 05Undoing the transfer did not buy a second judgment against the debtor
Judgment Creditor FAQ →

Most collection files are won or lost before the judgment is signed. A lawsuit takes a year or two. That is plenty of time for a debtor to sell the equipment, deed the house to a relative, or let the company run dry.

California gives a creditor tools to hold assets in place while the case is pending, and tools to pull assets back after they have been moved. Each tool has a narrow doorway. This part shows which door fits which file, and what happens to creditors who pick the wrong one.

Holding assets in place

01Attachment

The debtor’s cross-complaint did not stop the attachment

Lydig Construction, Inc. v. Martinez Steel Corp. (2015) 234 Cal.App.4th 937 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A general contractor on a county jail project sued its steel subcontractor for more than $200,000. Its evidence: the subcontractor could not buy steel, could not post its bonds, and had diverted 100,000 pounds of the contractor’s steel to other jobs. The contractor asked for a writ of attachment and backed the request with business records and employee declarations. The subcontractor answered with a one-employee declaration and, on the day of the hearing, a cross-complaint claiming it was owed more than it owed.

What the court decided

The trial court attached $203,315 and the Court of Appeal affirmed. A cross-complaint reduces an attachment only if the debtor’s own claim is one that could support an attachment, and that means the debtor must show its claim is probably valid. A bare statement that the debtor “will vehemently dispute” the numbers at trial was not evidence. The contractor’s accounting records and delivery log were.

DoBuild the attachment application like a trial exhibit binder: the contract, the invoices, the ledger, and a witness with personal knowledge of each number.
Don’tDon’t assume a counterclaim kills the remedy. And don’t file a thin application; the court weighs evidence, not accusations.
02Lis pendens

The same tool worked once the property had been transferred

Kirkeby v. Superior Court (2004) 33 Cal.4th 642 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A shareholder sued her brother and his wife, claiming they had looted the family company. One of her 27 claims was for fraudulent transfer. She alleged the couple had moved a rental property and the family home into a family limited partnership to defeat creditors, and she asked the court to void those transfers. She recorded a lis pendens on both properties. The trial court expunged it because the case was “primarily about money.”

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court reversed. A claim that asks the court to void a transfer of specific real property would, if it succeeds, affect title to that property. That makes it a real property claim, and it supports a lis pendens. The court acknowledged that the tool can be abused to pressure a settlement, and pointed to the other protections in the statute as the answer.

DoWhen real property has already been moved out of the debtor’s name, plead a claim to void that transfer and identify the property by address and legal description.
Don’tDon’t read this case as permission to tie up property the debtor still holds. That is the previous story.

When the assets have already moved

03Voidable transfers

The divorce papers were signed weeks after the tentative decision

Filip v. Bucurenciu (2005) 129 Cal.App.4th 825 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A creditor sued a man for fraud. Soon after the suit was filed, the man and his wife put four parcels into a family trust. After the judge announced a tentative decision for $249,000, the couple signed a property settlement giving the wife two of the parcels. A week later the wife and her daughter formed a corporation, and the trust deeded a parcel to it. Loan papers signed afterward still listed husband and wife together. The creditor’s judgment came to $366,388.77. He then sued the wife and the corporation to undo the transfers.

What the court decided

The creditor won, and the Court of Appeal affirmed. Intent to defraud is a question of fact, usually proved by circumstances: a transfer to an insider, made after the debtor was sued, with the debtor keeping control. A divorce settlement does not shield a transfer; the voidable-transfer law applies to it like any other. The trial court set the transfers aside and authorized the creditor to foreclose on two of the properties.

DoBuild a timeline. Put the lawsuit, the rulings, and every deed, entity filing, and loan application on one page. The pattern is the proof.
Don’tDon’t walk away because the transfer was papered as a divorce, a trust, or “estate planning.” Courts look at what happened and when.
04Voidable transfers

The partners’ draws were pay for work, not a fraud on the landlord

Annod Corp. v. Hamilton & Samuels (2002) 100 Cal.App.4th 1286 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A law firm stopped paying rent in September 1995 and dissolved in January 1996. The landlord got a judgment against the firm for $839,971.49 and collected nothing. It then sued the individual partners, arguing that every draw they took while the rent went unpaid, roughly $400,000, was a fraudulent transfer that should have gone to the landlord.

What the court decided

The partners won on summary judgment, and the Court of Appeal affirmed. The draws were payment for legal work the partners had actually done. They were smaller than in earlier periods and a fraction of the receivables the partners generated. Paying an existing debt is “value” under the statute, and a debtor may pay one creditor ahead of another. Three badges of fraud were present (insiders, pending litigation, insolvency), but badges do not create a presumption, and the landlord had no other evidence.

DoBefore you sue the people who got paid, ask what the debtor received in return. Wages, loan repayments, and trade payments usually count as value.
Don’tDon’t confuse “they paid someone else instead of me” with a voidable transfer. Preferring another creditor is not, by itself, fraud.

The debtor’s best counter: a transferee who took in good faith and gave reasonably equivalent value has a complete defense to an actual-intent claim (Civ. Code, § 3439.08, subd. (a)).

05Voidable transfers

Undoing the transfer did not buy a second judgment against the debtor

Renda v. Nevarez (2014) 223 Cal.App.4th 1231 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A creditor held an $817,429.55 judgment. The debtor did not pay and moved money to what the creditor called sham entities. He filed a second lawsuit to attack the transfers. A jury found the debtor had transferred $450,000 with intent to hinder, delay, or defraud him. He then asked for a new $450,000 money judgment against the debtor herself, on top of the first judgment.

What the court decided

The court said no, and the Court of Appeal affirmed. The creditor got the transfers voided and a $450,000 judgment against the entities that received the money. But the debtor already owed him that money under the first judgment. A second judgment against her for the same loss would be a double recovery. If the law should punish debtors more for moving assets, the court said, that is for the Legislature.

DoAim the transfer case at the people and entities that received the property. They are the new pockets.
Don’tDon’t budget a transfer case expecting a bigger judgment against the debtor. The goal is reach, not a larger number.
MythI have to wait for a judgment before I can touch the debtor’s assets.
RealityNot always. On a qualifying commercial contract claim, a court can attach assets at the start of the case. The bar is evidence that your claim is probably valid.
MythThe debtor owns a building, so I can record a lis pendens.
RealityOnly if your lawsuit is about title to or possession of that building. A claim for money is not. A claim to void a transfer of the building is (Kirkeby).
MythIt went to his wife in the divorce, so it is gone.
RealityA transfer under a marital settlement agreement can be attacked like any other transfer (Mejia; Filip).
MythAny payment the debtor made while owing me money can be clawed back.
RealityNo. A payment for real value, including payment of an existing debt, is generally safe even if it left nothing for you (Annod).

FAQ

Before judgment

Which claims should my complaint include?

Every claim the facts support, weighted toward the ones that help you collect. A written contract with an attorney-fee clause lets you add later enforcement fees to the judgment. A guaranty gives you a second pocket. An account stated or open book account can be simpler to prove. A fraud claim, where the facts honestly support it, may matter later if the debtor files bankruptcy. Name the debtor exactly as the name appears on title and bank records, with every alias and business name.

What does a court need to see before it will issue a writ of attachment?

A claim for money based on a contract, in a fixed or readily ascertainable amount of at least $500, that is commercial and not secured by real property. You must show by admissible evidence that you are more likely than not to win, and you must post an undertaking. Check the current undertaking amount before you file.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., §§ 481.190, 483.010, 484.090, 489.210; Lydig Construction, Inc. v. Martinez Steel Corp. (2015) 234 Cal.App.4th 937.

What is the risk if I attach and then lose?

You can be liable for wrongful attachment, which includes the debtor’s damages and attorney fees. An attachment lien also ends if the debtor files bankruptcy or makes a general assignment for creditors within 90 days after it was created.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., §§ 490.010, 490.020, 493.030.

What makes a transfer “voidable”?

Either of two things. First, the debtor made it with actual intent to hinder, delay, or defraud a creditor. Courts infer intent from the “badges of fraud” listed in the statute. Second, the debtor did not receive reasonably equivalent value and was insolvent or left with too little to operate. No bad intent is needed for the second kind.

Law:Civ. Code, §§ 3439.04, 3439.05; Filip v. Bucurenciu (2005) 129 Cal.App.4th 825.

How long do I have to attack a transfer?

Generally four years from the transfer. For an actual-intent claim, you also have one year from when the transfer was or reasonably could have been discovered, if that is later. Either way the claim is extinguished seven years after the transfer. That outer limit does not bend.

Law:Civ. Code, § 3439.09.

The debtor sold the whole business. Do I have a claim against the buyer?

Possibly. When a California business sells more than half of its inventory and equipment outside the ordinary course, the Bulk Sales Law requires advance notice to creditors. A buyer who skips the notice can be liable to the seller’s creditors. The time to sue is short, generally one year from the sale, so act quickly.

Law:Com. Code, §§ 6102, 6104, 6105, 6107, 6110.

Does the debtor’s unpaid future obligation make the debtor “insolvent”?

Not necessarily. The California Supreme Court held that future child support, which is paid from future income, is not counted as a present debt when testing insolvency. The same case confirmed that divorce transfers are open to attack for actual fraud.

Law:Mejia v. Reed (2003) 31 Cal.4th 657.

Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.

(310) 203-2650

Statewide California.