BENJY LAW CORPORATION

Judgment Creditor Resources · Part III of VI

Liens and finding the money

Record the lien first, then go find the assets. What an abstract of judgment must say, how liens rank, and how far a debtor’s examination and third-party examination can reach.

5 war storiesCalifornia lawFrom War Stories from the Judgment Docket

Talk to a lawyer: (310) 203-2650

General information about California law, not legal advice. Reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship.

In this part · 5 war stories
  1. 12“Unknown” was not true, and the lien was void
  2. 13The lien was recorded under a name that was not on title
  3. 14The creditor examined the debtor’s lawyer about his other clients
  4. 15“Where are the cars now?” was a fair question
  5. 16A notice of appeal stopped the contempt hearing
Judgment Creditor FAQ →

A judgment by itself attaches to nothing. Until you create a lien, the debtor can sell or borrow against property and other creditors can step ahead of you. Liens are cheap, they are quiet, and they set your place in line. That is why they come first.

Then comes the search. California lets a judgment creditor question the debtor under oath, demand documents, and examine third parties who hold the debtor’s property. These are strong tools with firm limits. The stories in this part show creditors who lost a lien over one blank on a form, and creditors who learned where the edges of an examination are.

Liens: your place in line

12Abstract of judgment

“Unknown” was not true, and the lien was void

Keele v. Reich (1985) 169 Cal.App.3d 1129 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A creditor won a money judgment in May 1981 and recorded an abstract of judgment that October. The form asked for the debtor’s Social Security and driver’s license numbers. The creditor marked both “unknown,” although the Social Security number appeared in an exhibit to her own verified complaint. After the abstract was recorded, the debtor transferred his interest in a property to his wife in their divorce. She sued for a declaration that the lien was invalid.

What the court decided

She won on appeal. The statute said the abstract “shall” contain the number if the creditor knows it. Leaving out required information that the creditor had, or could immediately get, nullified the abstract. It did not matter that no one was actually confused about who the debtor was. The question is whether the abstract complied with the statute, and the cases that excuse minor defects all involved abstracts that contained every required item.

DoFill in every blank on the abstract from your own file: the credit application, the complaint, the deposition. Today the form calls for the last four digits of the Social Security and driver’s license numbers, if known.
Don’tDon’t write “unknown” to save time. If the information is in your file, you know it.

Since this case: the statute now lets a creditor record an amendment to add a missing number, with priority back to the original recording date, except against a buyer or lender who took an interest in between without actual notice (Code Civ. Proc., § 674, subd. (b)).

13Abstract of judgment

The lien was recorded under a name that was not on title

Vasquez v. LBS Financial Credit Union (2020) 52 Cal.App.5th 97 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

In 2008 a credit union obtained two judgments and recorded abstracts against “Wilbert G. Guerrero.” The debtor held title to his house as Guillermo Guerrero. In 2015 he sold the house to a couple for $435,000. A title search under the name on the deed did not turn up the abstracts. One page of the purchase agreement had “Wilbert Guillermo Guerrero” handwritten under the seller’s signature. A year after closing, the credit union demanded $72,166.25 from the buyers and their lender and threatened to foreclose.

What the court decided

The buyers kept the house free of the liens. After a trial, the court found they were bona fide purchasers without notice, and the Court of Appeal affirmed. An abstract recorded under a name that is not in the chain of title does not give constructive notice. One handwritten name on a 10-page form did not put the buyers on inquiry. The burden is on the creditor to record under the name on title, not on a buyer to search every variation.

DoPull the vesting deed before you record. If title is held under a different name, get the additional name onto the abstract through an affidavit of identity, or amend the judgment.
Don’tDon’t record and forget. The credit union waited eight years to act, and by then the property had been sold.
Four judgment liens at a glance
LienHow you create itWhat it reachesHow long it lasts
Real property judgment lienRecord an abstract of judgment (form EJ-001) with the county recorderThe debtor’s real property interests in that county, including property acquired later. Not rents.10 years from entry of the judgment. Extended only if a certified copy of the renewal application is recorded before it expires.
Personal property judgment lienFile a notice of judgment lien (form JL-1) with the Secretary of StateListed business assets such as accounts receivable, equipment, and inventory. Not registered vehicles.5 years from filing. Can be continued.
Examination lienPersonally serve the debtor with the order to appear for examinationThe debtor’s nonexempt personal property1 year from the date of the order, unless the court extends it
Lien in a pending actionFile a notice of lien in the lawsuit where the debtor is a party, and serve the partiesWhatever the debtor recovers in that lawsuit, by judgment or settlementWhile that lawsuit is pending, until your judgment is satisfied or the lien is released

Finding the assets

14Third-party examinations

The creditor examined the debtor’s lawyer about his other clients

Fox Johns Lazar Pekin & Wexler, APC v. Superior Court (2013) 219 Cal.App.4th 1210 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

Creditors holding a judgment of more than $2.7 million examined the debtor company’s chief financial officer and received a large document production. They then obtained an order to examine the debtor’s trial lawyer as a third party, and subpoenaed his firm’s records. Their questions went to the firm’s other clients, its billings for those clients, and entities that might be alter egos of the debtor. The trial court ordered some answers and some documents.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal directed the trial court to quash the order and the subpoena. The third-party examination statute lets a creditor examine someone who holds the debtor’s property or owes the debtor more than $250, about that property or that debt. It does not allow a wider examination. The creditors were free to apply again for an examination that stayed inside those limits.

DoState in the application exactly what property of the debtor the third party holds, or what the third party owes, and keep the questions there.
Don’tDon’t use a third-party examination order as a general investigation of the witness’s own business.
15Third-party examinations

“Where are the cars now?” was a fair question

Yolanda’s, Inc. v. Kahl & Goveia Commercial Real Estate (2017) 11 Cal.App.5th 509 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A restaurant company held a $1,892,835 judgment in a lease dispute. A related property management company, named in the judgment until an appeal removed it, had shut down claiming insolvency. One of its principals had started a new management company, and its assets and key employees moved there. At a third-party examination, the old company’s accountant produced papers showing vehicles, leases, and equipment had been transferred to the two principals. His lawyer told him not to say where those assets were now, arguing the statute covers only property the witness still holds.

What the court decided

The trial court ordered the questions answered, and the Court of Appeal left that order in place. Whatever the limits of the third-party examination statute, a companion statute lets a creditor subpoena any witness with information that would help enforce the judgment, and the court has inherent power to shape a fair procedure. The policy of the law favors enforcing judgments. No policy favors concealing a debtor’s assets.

DoWhen a witness cuts off questions, take the dispute to the judge and cite both the third-party statute and the witness statute.
Don’tDon’t accept “I no longer have it” as the end of the examination. Where it went is the point.
16Appeals

A notice of appeal stopped the contempt hearing

Macaluso v. Superior Court (2013) 219 Cal.App.4th 1042 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A homebuilder held a judgment of more than $50 million and believed the debtor was hiding assets. It subpoenaed a lawyer who had lent the debtor money and represented him, demanding documents at an examination. The lawyer objected. The trial court overruled every objection and ordered production. The lawyer filed a notice of appeal and did not produce. The trial court, viewing the order as an unappealable discovery ruling, set a contempt hearing.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal ordered the contempt proceeding vacated. For a third party who is not part of any ongoing lawsuit, an order compelling production is final as to that person. The court held it was appealable, so the appeal stayed the order. Other courts have since disagreed. Days later a different panel of the same court declined to treat a similar order as appealable, and a later decision called that the better general rule because appeals from each discovery order invite delay and concealment.

DoPlan for delay when you subpoena a resistant third party. Serve early, and keep other enforcement moving in the meantime.
Don’tDon’t press a contempt hearing while an appeal of the same order is pending until the court decides whether the order is appealable.

FAQ

Liens and discovery

What does recording an abstract of judgment actually do?

It creates a lien on the debtor’s real property interests in that county, including property the debtor acquires there later. The debtor usually cannot sell or refinance with clear title without paying you. The lien lasts 10 years from entry of the judgment. Renewing the judgment does not extend the lien unless a certified copy of the renewal application is recorded before the lien expires.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., §§ 674, 683.180, 697.310, 697.340.

Why is the debtor’s examination usually the first discovery step?

Because it does three things at once. The debtor must answer under oath about assets. Personal service of the order creates a one-year lien on the debtor’s personal property. And a debtor who was properly served and does not appear can be brought in on a warrant and ordered to pay your attorney fees.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., §§ 708.110, 708.170.

How often can I examine the debtor or send interrogatories?

Generally once every 120 days. A second examination inside 120 days needs a showing of good cause. Written interrogatories cannot be served within 120 days after the debtor answered an earlier set or was examined. Make the first round thorough.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., §§ 708.020, 708.110.

Can I examine someone other than the debtor?

Yes, if you can show the court that the person holds property in which the debtor has an interest, or owes the debtor more than $250. The examination is about that property or debt. Separately, witnesses with relevant information can be subpoenaed to testify at an examination.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., §§ 708.120, 708.130; Fox Johns Lazar Pekin & Wexler, APC v. Superior Court (2013) 219 Cal.App.4th 1210; Yolanda’s, Inc. v. Kahl & Goveia Commercial Real Estate (2017) 11 Cal.App.5th 509.

The examination turned up an asset. Now what?

Ask the court, at the end of the examination, to order the property applied to the judgment. That order also creates a lien. If a third party claims the property as its own or denies owing the debt, the court generally cannot order a turnover on the spot, but it can forbid a transfer while the dispute is resolved.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., §§ 708.180, 708.205.

The debtor is suing someone else. Can I get in line for that money?

Yes. File a notice of lien in that lawsuit and serve the parties. After that the debtor generally cannot settle or collect in that case without satisfying your lien or getting your consent or a court order.

Law:Code Civ. Proc., §§ 708.410–708.480.

Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.

(310) 203-2650

Statewide California.