BENJY LAW CORPORATION

Judgment Creditor Resources · Part IV of VI

Levies, garnishment and sales

A writ of execution turns a judgment into money, if you levy on the right asset at the right time and answer every claim on time. This part covers bank levies, wage garnishment, sales, and the clocks that sink creditors.

4 war storiesCalifornia lawFrom War Stories from the Judgment Docket

Talk to a lawyer: (310) 203-2650

General information about California law, not legal advice. Reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship.

In this part · 4 war stories
  1. 17“Don’t owe any money”
  2. 18The antique dealers’ “tools of the trade”
  3. 19Right on the law, but too late
  4. 20The sheriff’s sale that could not be undone
Judgment Creditor FAQ →

A judgment does not collect itself. The court will not look for the debtor’s money, and the sheriff will not go looking either. You get a writ of execution, you tell the levying officer exactly what to take and where, and you pay the fees in advance.

Then the clocks start. The debtor has days to claim an exemption. You have days to oppose it. A stranger may claim the property is his. Most of the stories in this part were won or lost on a deadline, or on what the creditor could prove at a short hearing.

How a levy works

The main levies at a glance
RemedyWhat it reachesKey formsKey clock
Bank levyOnly the money on deposit at the moment the bank is served. Accounts in someone else’s name usually need a court order first.Writ of Execution (EJ-130); Notice of Levy (EJ-150)Levy within 180 days of the writ. Debtor’s exemption claim: 15 days (20 if served by mail).
Wage garnishmentA capped share of an employee’s disposable earnings, paid over each pay period. Not available against the self-employed.Application for Earnings Withholding Order (WG-001); Earnings Withholding Order (WG-002)Serve the employer within 180 days of the writ. Oppose a claim of exemption within 10 days after the notice is mailed.
Levy on money owed to the debtorRents, receivables, loans, and other debts a third person owes the debtor.EJ-130; EJ-150; the third person returns a garnishee’s memorandumGarnishee’s memorandum is due 10 days after service.
Levy on real propertyThe debtor’s interest in land. The officer records the writ and notice of levy.EJ-130; EJ-150No notice of sale until 120 days after the notice of levy is served on the debtor.
Sale of a dwellingA natural person’s home. Requires a court order for sale after a hearing on the homestead exemption.Application for order for sale; Notice of Hearing (EJ-180)Apply within 20 days after the levying officer’s notice, or the levy is released.

When someone else holds the money

17Garnishee liability

“Don’t owe any money”

Evans v. Paye (1995) 32 Cal.App.4th 265 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A creditor held a judgment of about $886,000 against a married couple who had guaranteed their son’s note. The sheriff served a levy on another son and asked him to complete a sworn garnishee’s memorandum. He wrote: “Don’t owe any money.” At his debtor’s examination, the father testified that he had lent that son $35,000 and expected to be repaid with interest. The son then called it a “moral obligation,” not a loan, and said a creditor’s only remedy was a separate lawsuit against him.

What the court decided

The trial court ordered the $35,000 applied to the judgment, and the Court of Appeal affirmed. Once the creditor shows evidence that a third person owes the debtor money, the third person must prove that his denial is made in good faith. A story that merely sounds plausible is not enough. The court looks at all the circumstances. If the denial is not in good faith, the court can decide the matter on the spot, with no separate creditor’s suit. The son was also ordered to pay fees for the incomplete memorandum.

DoExamine the debtor under oath about loans to relatives and friends, then use that testimony against the person who received the money.
Don’tDon’t accept a one-line garnishee’s memorandum from someone close to the debtor. Test it at an examination.

Exemptions

18Claims of exemption

The antique dealers’ “tools of the trade”

Kono v. Meeker (2011) 196 Cal.App.4th 81 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A creditor held a California judgment, based on an Iowa judgment, with about $317,000 unpaid. The debtors were a married couple who sold antique tools and mechanical devices, mostly on consignment for others. After a debtor’s examination the court ordered them to turn over 11 items to the levying officer. They filed claims of exemption. Their main argument was that the antiques they owned and offered for sale were exempt as “tools of the trade,” because the pieces attracted consignors. The creditor opposed the claims.

What the court decided

The trial court denied the exemption, and the Court of Appeal affirmed. The exemption protects property a debtor actually uses to carry on a trade, such as a shop’s computers, cash registers, and racks. Goods held for sale are inventory. The court noted that the person claiming an exemption has the burden of proof, and that courts cannot enlarge the exemptions the Legislature wrote.

DoOppose a doubtful claim of exemption on time and make the debtor prove it. The burden is on the person claiming the exemption.
Don’tDon’t release a levy because the debtor used the word “exempt.” Read which exemption is claimed and what it actually covers.

Selling the debtor’s home

19Order for sale of a dwelling

Right on the law, but too late

Rourke v. Troy (1993) 17 Cal.App.4th 880 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

Creditors who were owed about $461,000 on their judgments levied on the debtor’s home and applied for a court order to sell it. The trial court refused. It read the homestead statute to forbid any sale unless the expected bid would cover the homestead exemption, the mortgage, and the creditors’ own judgments in full. With appraisals topping out at $325,000, that was impossible.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal rejected that reading. The minimum bid must exceed the homestead exemption plus the liens that are senior to the levying creditor. It need not pay the creditor’s own judgment in full, as long as something is left to apply to it. But the creditors still lost. Their application for the order of sale had not been filed within the time the statute allows after the levying officer’s notice, so denial was correct on that ground. They were free to apply again if they met the deadline.

DoCalendar the 20-day deadline to apply for an order of sale the day you instruct the levy on a dwelling. Have the title report and appraisal ready first.
Don’tDon’t levy on a home until you have run the numbers: likely bid, minus senior liens, minus the homestead exemption, minus costs.

Note: The homestead exemption is far larger today than in 1993, and it changes. Check the current amount before you levy. Code Civ. Proc. § 704.730.

20Execution sales

The sheriff’s sale that could not be undone

Gonzalez v. Toews (2003) 111 Cal.App.4th 977 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A creditor levied on a judgment debtor’s 22-acre parcel. The debtor filed bankruptcy, telling the bankruptcy court he lived elsewhere and the parcel was unimproved land. After the bankruptcy was dismissed, the sheriff sold the parcel to two outside buyers. The debtor then sued to set the sale aside. He said he had since moved into a house on the land, so it was a dwelling that could be sold only with a court order.

What the court decided

He lost. By statute an execution sale is absolute and may not be set aside for any reason, with one exception: when the buyer is the judgment creditor, the debtor has 90 days to sue to undo an improper sale. Against outside buyers the debtor’s remedy is money damages from the creditor or the levying officer. And because he moved in after the levy, he had no homestead to protect in the first place.

DoIf you plan to bid your judgment and buy the property yourself, make the procedure spotless. You are the one buyer whose sale can be set aside.
Don’tDon’t skip the order for sale when the property might be someone’s home. Even when the sale stands, the creditor can owe damages.

Note: The statute was later amended to state that the debtor’s equitable right of redemption is preserved. Code Civ. Proc. § 701.680.

When a stranger claims the property

FAQ

Levies and garnishment

How long is a writ of execution good for?

You must levy within 180 days after the clerk issues it. A levy made in time creates a lien that lasts until two years after the writ’s issue date. You need a separate writ for each county.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. §§ 699.510, 699.530, 697.710.

I served a bank levy and got $40. The debtor deposited a large check the next week. Do I get that?

No. A bank levy reaches what is in the account when the bank is served, not later deposits. Timing matters. To reach later deposits you levy again.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 700.140.

The money is in an account under the debtor’s spouse’s or company’s name. Can I levy on it?

Usually only with a court order first, or with the showing the statute requires for a spouse’s account. Banks will not honor a levy on an account that does not stand in the debtor’s name without it.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 700.160.

How much of a paycheck can I garnish?

A capped percentage of disposable earnings, set by statute and tied to the minimum wage. The cap has changed in recent years. The employer’s instructions on the current Judicial Council form show the present figures.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. §§ 706.050, 706.051; form WG-002.

Someone owes my debtor money and denies it. Do I have to file a new lawsuit?

Not always. After a third-party examination, the court can decide whether the debt exists if the denial is not made in good faith. If the dispute is genuine, the court may leave it to a separate creditor’s suit.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 708.180; Evans v. Paye (1995) 32 Cal.App.4th 265.

Can I force the sale of the debtor’s house?

Sometimes. You need a levy, a timely application, and a court order for sale. The bid must exceed the homestead exemption plus senior liens, and generally must reach 90 percent of the value the court finds. If no bid qualifies, the home is released and you cannot try again for a year. Judgments on consumer debts face added limits on selling a principal residence.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. §§ 704.740–704.800, 699.730; Rourke v. Troy (1993) 17 Cal.App.4th 880.

Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.

(310) 203-2650

Statewide California.