BENJY LAW CORPORATION

Judgment Creditor Resources · Part V of VI

Hard-to-reach assets and hard-to-catch debtors

Some assets cannot be levied on at all: an LLC interest, a commission stream, a house in a living trust. This part covers the tools built for them, and what happens to debtors who defy the court.

5 war storiesCalifornia lawFrom War Stories from the Judgment Docket

Talk to a lawyer: (310) 203-2650

General information about California law, not legal advice. Reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship.

In this part · 5 war stories
  1. 21The receiver the creditor had not earned yet
  2. 22The “blind trust” signed the day before judgment
  3. 23The life insurance trust the creditors could not crack
  4. 24Forty-seven transfers and no appeal
  5. 25The claim of exemption that claimed no exemption
Judgment Creditor FAQ →

A writ of execution reaches the easy things: a bank account, a paycheck, a parcel in the debtor’s own name. Debtors with something to lose rarely keep it there. The money sits in an LLC, arrives as commissions, or is held by a trust.

California gives you a separate tool for each of these. Each is a motion to a judge, not a form handed to the sheriff, so each needs evidence. This part also covers the debtor who answers every order with silence, a transfer, or another motion.

Tools for assets a levy cannot reach

21Receivers

The receiver the creditor had not earned yet

Medipro Medical Staffing LLC v. Certified Nursing Registry, Inc. (2021) 60 Cal.App.5th 622 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A staffing company won a judgment of more than $2 million against a competitor and its founder. It levied on bank accounts and on hospitals that owed the debtor money, and collected about $409,000. Then the hospital payments stopped. The creditor’s lawyer suspected the debtor was billing under another name and asked for a receiver to take over the business’s accounts, books, and mail. The trial court struck the lawyer’s suspicions as inadmissible but appointed the receiver anyway.

What the court decided

Reversed. A receiver is a drastic and costly remedy, and ordinarily may not be used to collect a simple money judgment. The creditor needs evidence that the debtor has obstructed collection, and that less intrusive tools have not worked. Here there was no admissible proof of evasion, and the creditor had not served interrogatories, recorded liens, or completed a debtor’s examination. The court left the door open to a new motion on better evidence.

DoUse the cheaper tools first and keep a record of each one: what you served, what came back, and what the debtor did to dodge it.
Don’tDon’t ask for a receiver on your lawyer’s hunch. Bring sworn facts from people with personal knowledge.

Trusts

22Living trusts

The “blind trust” signed the day before judgment

Keitel v. Heubel (2002) 103 Cal.App.4th 324 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A jury awarded a woman $361,267 against her brother and his wife for fraud and undue influence over their mother’s estate. The day before judgment was entered, the couple deeded four properties to trustees of a new “blind trust.” The trust document called itself a revocable living trust and reserved their right to revoke it at any time. When the creditor levied, the couple wrote the sheriff that they were “not the owners of record.” The sheriff would not go forward without a court order.

What the court decided

The creditor got the order, and the Court of Appeal affirmed it. When the person who creates a trust keeps the power to revoke it, the trust property stays subject to that person’s creditors. A writ of execution could issue against the trustees. The court also found the appeal frivolous, taken to delay collection, and sanctioned the debtors and their lawyer. The debtors’ bankruptcy filing did not stop the court from imposing those sanctions.

DoGet the trust instrument. If the debtor can revoke it, ask the court for an order that the writ may issue against the trustees.
Don’tDon’t accept “the trust owns it” as the end of the conversation, and don’t expect the sheriff to sort it out without an order.
23Irrevocable trusts

The life insurance trust the creditors could not crack

Laycock v. Hammer (2006) 141 Cal.App.4th 25 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

Creditors held a $4.65 million judgment against a man who died weeks later. Thirteen years earlier he had put a life insurance policy into a trust that declared itself irrevocable. The insurer paid about $767,000 to the trustee. The creditors argued that he had treated the trust as his own: he acted as a co-trustee, borrowed against the policy, and dealt with the insurer himself. That conduct, they said, made the trust revocable in fact.

What the court decided

The creditors lost on summary judgment, and the Court of Appeal affirmed. Whether a trust is revocable is decided from the words of the trust instrument. The statutes let a settlor’s creditors reach only revocable-trust property, and a settlor’s later conduct does not convert an irrevocable trust into a revocable one. Creditors are bound by the instrument like everyone else.

DoRead the instrument first, and check when the asset went in. A recent transfer into an irrevocable trust may be attacked as a voidable transfer, which is a different claim with its own deadlines.
Don’tDon’t spend the budget proving the debtor “really controlled” an irrevocable trust. Under this decision, control is not the test.

Debtors who defy the court

24Disentitlement

Forty-seven transfers and no appeal

Gwartz v. Weilert (2014) 231 Cal.App.4th 750 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

Buyers of a rural property won a $1,553,800 fraud judgment against the sellers, a physician and his wife. The debtors appealed but posted no bond, so collection went ahead. After a debtor’s examination turned up about $225,000 in a family partnership account, the trial court froze the debtors’ and their entities’ assets, then issued turnover, assignment, and charging orders. The creditors later showed 47 transfers of money made in violation of those orders. The debtor did not deny that the transfers happened.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal dismissed the debtors’ appeal without reaching its merits. Under the disentitlement doctrine, a court may refuse to hear a party who is willfully disobeying valid court orders. No formal contempt finding is needed. It would be unjust, the court said, to let the debtors seek the benefits of an appeal while frustrating legitimate efforts to enforce the judgment.

DoDocument every violation of an enforcement order with dates and amounts. If the debtor has an appeal pending, move to dismiss it.
Don’tDon’t stop collecting because the debtor appealed. Without a bond, the judgment is enforceable while the appeal is pending.
25Serial motions

The claim of exemption that claimed no exemption

Bank of California v. Varakin (1990) 216 Cal.App.3d 1630 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

After years of litigation over the sale of a San Francisco property, a law firm held a court-ordered attorney fee award against a lawyer and levied on his bank account to collect it. He filed a “claim of exemption.” It gave no reason the account was exempt. It repeated complaints about earlier rulings that he had already lost. He also filed repeated motions to declare the fee award void. This was his fourth, fifth, and sixth appeal in the case.

What the court decided

The trial court denied the claim and imposed sanctions for each frivolous filing. The Court of Appeal affirmed, found the appeals frivolous as well, and added more than $37,000 in sanctions, including $25,000 payable to the court. The debtor, it said, had “consistently abused every legal process available to him to delay fulfillment of his obligations.”

DoOppose a baseless filing on the merits and ask for sanctions in the same papers. Keep a running history of the debtor’s filings to show the pattern.
Don’tDon’t ignore a frivolous claim of exemption. An unopposed claim can release the levy, however weak it is.
MythI have a judgment against the owner, so I can levy on the LLC’s bank account.
RealityNo. The LLC is a separate person and is not your debtor. Your tools are a charging order against the owner’s interest, or a motion to add the entity to the judgment if the facts support it.
MythAnything in a trust is out of reach.
RealityNot if the debtor created the trust and can revoke it. That property remains open to the debtor’s creditors (Keitel). An irrevocable trust is a different matter (Laycock).
MythA receiver is the fastest way to collect.
RealityIt is the most expensive, and courts treat it as a last resort. Without proof of obstruction and of failed lesser remedies, an appointment can be reversed (Medipro).
MythThe debtor appealed, so everything stops.
RealityAn appeal from a money judgment stops nothing unless the debtor posts a bond. And a debtor who defies enforcement orders can lose the appeal itself (Gwartz).

FAQ

Hard-to-reach assets

My debtor owns part of an LLC. Can the sheriff seize that interest?

No. An owner’s interest in a partnership or LLC is reached by a charging order, obtained by motion. The order directs the entity to pay you whatever it would otherwise distribute to the debtor. If nothing is distributed, you can ask the court to foreclose on the interest.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 708.310; Corp. Code §§ 16504, 17705.03.

The debtor is paid in commissions, not wages. What do I use?

An assignment order. Wage garnishment reaches only an employee’s earnings. For commissions, royalties, rents, and similar payment streams, the court can order the debtor’s right to payment assigned to you, up to the amount of the judgment.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 708.510.

When will a court appoint a receiver to collect a judgment?

When you show it is a reasonable way to get the judgment satisfied fairly, considering both sides. In practice that means evidence that the debtor has evaded collection and that ordinary tools have failed or cannot reach the asset.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 708.620; Medipro Medical Staffing LLC v. Certified Nursing Registry, Inc. (2021) 60 Cal.App.5th 622.

The debtor moved the house into a living trust. Now what?

If the debtor kept the power to revoke the trust, the property is still subject to the debtor’s creditors. You may need a court order confirming that before the levying officer will act.

Law:Prob. Code § 18200; Keitel v. Heubel (2002) 103 Cal.App.4th 324.

The debtor is a beneficiary of a trust someone else set up. Can I levy on it?

Not by writ of execution. A beneficiary’s interest in a trust is reached by a petition in the court that supervises the trust, and spendthrift provisions may limit what you can get. This is a specialized procedure. Get advice before you file.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. §§ 699.720, 709.010.

Can a debtor go to jail for ignoring enforcement orders?

Contempt is available, but the rules are strict and the order being enforced must itself be valid. In one case a contempt finding was thrown out because the examination order had been signed by a disqualified judge, and an open-ended jail term lasting until he paid failed for lack of proof that the debtor could pay right then.

Law:Noorthoek v. Superior Court (1969) 269 Cal.App.2d 600.

Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.

(310) 203-2650

Statewide California.