BENJY LAW CORPORATION

Lender Resources · Part III of V

Workouts, modifications and forbearance

Most loans that end up in court were “worked out” first. See how accepted late payments, a phone call about postponing a sale, and an unsigned forbearance agreement changed the outcome, and how to paper a workout so it holds.

6 war storiesCalifornia lawFrom War Stories from the Loan File

Talk to a lawyer: (310) 203-2650

General information about California law, not legal advice. Reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship.

In this part · 6 war stories
  1. 14A year of short payments did not rewrite the note
  2. 15Two years at the lower rate were gone for good
  3. 16The branch took the payment. The trustee sold the house anyway.
  4. 17“All we want is our money” led to a $475,000 verdict
  5. 18The forbearance agreement only one side signed
  6. 19The workout traded lower payments for a waiver that was void
Lender FAQ →

A loan in trouble rarely goes straight to foreclosure. First come the late payments you accept, the calls asking for more time, and the “let’s see where we are next month.” Each one feels like patience. In court, each one is evidence.

Borrowers use that evidence to argue that you changed the deal, gave up a default, or promised not to foreclose. The cases in this part show where those arguments worked, where they failed, and what a clean workout file looks like.

Accepting late and partial payments

14Waiver

A year of short payments did not rewrite the note

Hunt v. Smyth (1972) 25 Cal.App.3d 807 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A note secured by a second deed of trust called for payments of $250 a month, rising to $350 in January 1968. The borrowers kept paying $250, often late. The holder took the money for more than a year without objecting to the amount. In March 1969 he wrote that he would accept nothing less than the full $350 going forward and gave a date to catch up. The borrowers kept sending $250 checks. He recorded a notice of default and returned the checks. The borrowers sued to stop the sale, claiming the note had been changed to $250.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal sided with the note holder. Simply accepting part of what is due does not discharge the rest or change the payment terms. A modification or novation needs an agreement and consideration, and the borrowers had to prove it. Whatever leniency the holder had shown ended with his written demand. After that letter the short payments were not enough to cure the default.

DoWhen you decide the leniency is over, say so in a dated letter: the exact amount due, the date it is due, and that you will insist on the loan terms from then on.
Don’tDon’t go straight from months of accepting short payments to a notice of default. Give the written warning first.
15Waiver

Two years at the lower rate were gone for good

Thompson v. Gorner (1894) 104 Cal. 168 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A note carried 8 percent interest, and a higher rate of 1 percent a month if principal or interest was not paid when due. The note matured unpaid. For nearly two years the holder kept accepting monthly interest at the lower rate. Then she refused the next payment and demanded the higher rate. The borrower tendered principal plus interest at the lower rate. She sued to foreclose.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court split the result. For every month she had accepted the lower rate, the higher rate was waived and could not be collected later. But accepting less in the past did not change the note for the future. From the day she refused the lower payment and demanded the contract rate, she was entitled to it.

DoDecide when a default happens whether you are charging what the note allows, and put that in writing to the borrower.
Don’tDon’t accept payments month after month as if nothing changed and expect to bill the difference later.

Note: this old case was decided under an earlier version of Civ. Code § 1698, and the whole note had already come due. The rule on when a higher rate after default is enforceable at all is covered in Part I.

16Reinstatement

The branch took the payment. The trustee sold the house anyway.

Bank of America v. La Jolla Group II (2005) 129 Cal.App.4th 706 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A $15,000 loan secured by a house in Fresno went into default, and the lender’s trustee set a sale. Four days before the sale, a payment curing the default was handed to a branch employee, who accepted it and reinstated the loan. Nobody told the trustee. The sale went forward and a professional foreclosure buyer bid $15,500 for a house he valued at $115,000. He recorded his deed and refused to give it back.

What the court decided

The sale was void. A power of sale exists only while there is a default. Once lender and borrower agreed to cure the default and reinstate, there was nothing left to foreclose on, even though the statutory reinstatement period had already ended. The buyer’s deed recitals did not save him. The lender had to sue its own foreclosure buyer to undo the sale.

DoHave one person control every loan in foreclosure. Any payment or agreement goes to that person and to the trustee the same day.
Don’tDon’t let a branch, servicer, or loan officer accept money on a loan in foreclosure without checking with whoever is running the sale.

Note: this was a home loan, but the court’s reasoning rests on the deed of trust itself and is not limited to home loans.

Promises to wait

17Oral promises

“All we want is our money” led to a $475,000 verdict

Raedeke v. Gibraltar Savings & Loan Assn. (1974) 10 Cal.3d 665 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A lender held a $730,000 first deed of trust on a motor hotel and restaurant and had a trustee’s sale scheduled. The owners said the lender’s agent orally agreed to postpone the sale again if they found a responsible buyer for the property, and told them more than once that the lender would cooperate. They found a buyer. The lender held the sale anyway, bought the property itself for the debt, and the owners sued for damages.

What the court decided

A jury found that the promise was made and awarded $475,000. The trial judge set that aside. The California Supreme Court reinstated the verdict. An oral promise to postpone a sale given for nothing is ordinarily not enforceable. But here the owners gave something they did not already owe: they went out and found a buyer at the lender’s request. That was consideration, so the claim was an ordinary contract claim for a jury.

DoIf you agree to postpone a sale, put the new date and every condition in a short signed writing. If you will not postpone, say that in writing too.
Don’tDon’t let anyone tell a borrower in default “we’ll work with you” or “bring us a buyer and we’ll hold off” unless you mean to be held to it.

Note: the court decided only that the borrowers were entitled to the jury’s verdict. It did not review the merits of that verdict. Civ. Code § 1698 has been rewritten since, and later cases apply the statute of frauds to these promises (see Secrest, below).

18Forbearance agreements

The forbearance agreement only one side signed

Secrest v. Security National Mortgage Loan Trust 2002-2 (2008) 167 Cal.App.4th 544 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

Borrowers in default negotiated a new forbearance agreement by phone with the lender’s representative. He faxed a draft with an obviously wrong reinstatement figure, told them to cross it out, sign, fax it back, and wire $13,422.51, and promised an audit and a corrected agreement. They signed and paid. The lender never signed. The loan was sold, the audit never happened, and years later the new holder recorded a notice of default. The borrowers sued to block the sale.

What the court decided

The lender won. An agreement to forbear from foreclosing modifies the note and deed of trust, so it falls under the statute of frauds and must be signed by the party it is enforced against. The lender had not signed. Paying money was not enough to get around the missing signature, because money can be refunded or credited.

DoTreat a forbearance agreement like a loan document: correct numbers, full signatures on both sides, and a copy in the file that travels with the loan.
Don’tDon’t let workout terms live in phone notes and half-signed faxes. The lender here won, but only after an injunction and years in court over a draft.

Note: this was a home loan. The court relied on general contract statutes that apply to commercial deeds of trust as well. The same rule can cut against a lender trying to enforce workout terms the borrower never signed.

19Workout waivers

The workout traded lower payments for a waiver that was void

DeBerard Properties, Ltd. v. Lim (1999) 20 Cal.4th 659 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A seller sold a shopping center and carried back a note secured by a junior deed of trust. When the buyers could not keep up, the parties signed a forbearance agreement. The seller cut the monthly payment and the interest rate in half and agreed not to foreclose. In exchange, the buyers waived the antideficiency protection of Code Civ. Proc. § 580b. They defaulted again, the senior lender foreclosed, and the seller sued on the note. The trial court enforced the waiver.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court did not. As it then read, § 580b barred a deficiency on seller purchase-money paper “in any event.” A buyer cannot waive it, at closing or later, even for real concessions. The court agreed that ruinous concessions are, if anything, easier to get from a borrower already in default. The seller gave up half its payments and got nothing enforceable in return.

DoBefore you give concessions in exchange for a waiver, have counsel confirm the waiver is one California will enforce.
Don’tDon’t price a workout on the assumption that a borrower’s waiver of antideficiency protection will hold.

Scope: § 580b covers seller carry-back financing, certain home-purchase loans and, for loans made since 2013, refinancings of those home loans. It does not cover an ordinary commercial loan from a third-party lender. The statute has been reworded since DeBerard and no longer says “in any event.” See Part IV.

MythIf I take a late payment, I have waived the default.
RealityNot by itself. Accepting late or partial payments does not rewrite the note (Hunt v. Smyth). But a pattern of acceptance can require you to give clear notice, best given in writing, before you enforce strictly again.
MythOur note says “no oral modifications,” so nothing said on the phone can hurt us.
RealityThe clause helps, but it is not a shield. An oral promise backed by something new from the borrower supported a damages verdict in Raedeke, decided under an earlier version of the statute. Under today’s Civ. Code § 1698, an oral change both sides have carried out, waiver, and estoppel all remain available.
MythA forbearance agreement is just a letter. It doesn’t need both signatures.
RealityIt changes the note and deed of trust, so it must be in a writing signed by the party to be held to it (Secrest).
MythThe reinstatement deadline has passed, so we can take the payment and still hold the sale.
RealityIf you accept a cure and reinstate by agreement, the power to sell on that default is gone (La Jolla Group II).

FAQ

Workouts and modifications

Can a written loan be changed by a conversation?

Sometimes. A written contract can be modified by another writing, by an oral agreement to the extent both sides have carried it out, or, unless the contract says otherwise, by an oral agreement supported by new consideration. If the modified contract is one the statute of frauds covers, the modification must satisfy it too. Waiver and estoppel are preserved.

Law:Civ. Code § 1698, subds. (a)–(d); Secrest v. Security National Mortgage Loan Trust 2002-2 (2008) 167 Cal.App.4th 544.

Does accepting a late or partial payment waive my right to call a default?

Not by itself. Accepting part of what is due does not discharge the rest or change the terms. But the months you accepted at a lower figure may be gone, and after a pattern of leniency you should give clear written notice before enforcing strictly.

Law:Hunt v. Smyth (1972) 25 Cal.App.3d 807; Thompson v. Gorner (1894) 104 Cal. 168.

The borrower says our dealings created a “new deal” that replaced the note. Is that a novation?

Only if it clearly appears that both sides intended to extinguish the old obligation and substitute a new one, with consideration. The party claiming a novation has the burden of proving it.

Law:Civ. Code §§ 1530–1532; Hunt v. Smyth, 25 Cal.App.3d 807.

Is an oral promise to postpone a trustee’s sale binding?

A bare promise given for nothing ordinarily is not. A promise the borrower paid for with something new, such as finding a buyer at your request, has supported a damages verdict. An agreement to forbear from foreclosing must also satisfy the statute of frauds. The safe practice is to make no oral promises about a sale at all.

Law:Raedeke v. Gibraltar Savings & Loan Assn. (1974) 10 Cal.3d 665; Secrest, 167 Cal.App.4th 544.

Can we accept a reinstatement payment after the statutory deadline?

Yes, lender and borrower may agree to cure and reinstate after the statutory period. But once you accept it, you cannot foreclose on that default, and a sale held anyway is invalid.

Law:Bank of America v. La Jolla Group II (2005) 129 Cal.App.4th 706; Civ. Code § 2924c, subd. (e).

Can the borrower waive foreclosure and antideficiency protections in a workout?

It depends on the protection and the timing. A borrower’s waiver of the notice, reinstatement, fair-value, and one-action protections made when the loan is made or renewed is void by statute. The borrower cannot waive the purchase-money bar of § 580b at any time. Have counsel review any waiver before you give value for it.

Law:Civ. Code § 2953; DeBerard Properties, Ltd. v. Lim (1999) 20 Cal.4th 659.

Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.

(310) 203-2650

Statewide California.