A year of short payments did not rewrite the note
Hunt v. Smyth (1972) 25 Cal.App.3d 807 · California Court of Appeal
What happened
A note secured by a second deed of trust called for payments of $250 a month, rising to $350 in January 1968. The borrowers kept paying $250, often late. The holder took the money for more than a year without objecting to the amount. In March 1969 he wrote that he would accept nothing less than the full $350 going forward and gave a date to catch up. The borrowers kept sending $250 checks. He recorded a notice of default and returned the checks. The borrowers sued to stop the sale, claiming the note had been changed to $250.
What the court decided
The Court of Appeal sided with the note holder. Simply accepting part of what is due does not discharge the rest or change the payment terms. A modification or novation needs an agreement and consideration, and the borrowers had to prove it. Whatever leniency the holder had shown ended with his written demand. After that letter the short payments were not enough to cure the default.