The broker only filled in the blanks
Gibbo v. Berger (2004) 123 Cal.App.4th 396 · California Court of Appeal
What happened
In 1992 a private lender made a $15,000 loan at 15 percent, secured by a deed of trust on the borrowers’ home. An escrow company owned by a licensed real estate broker typed the agreed terms into preprinted forms, ordered title insurance, and paid out the money, for a $100 fee. The borrowers made monthly interest payments over ten years. When the lender’s daughter started foreclosure to collect the principal, the borrower sued for usury. The lender’s side answered that the loan was exempt because a licensed broker had “arranged” it.
What the court decided
The Court of Appeal reversed a judgment for the lender. To “arrange” a loan, a broker must act as an intermediary who causes the loan to be made, for example by structuring it, setting the rate, or drafting its terms. This broker did none of that. She acted like “a scribe.” With no exemption, 15 percent was usurious. The lender was entitled to principal only, and the borrowers’ payments had already exceeded it, so the debt was satisfied and the deed of trust had to come off.