A hope of refinancing was not a tender
Karlsen v. American Savings & Loan Assn. (1971) 15 Cal.App.3d 112 · California Court of Appeal
What happened
A lender held a trustee’s sale and bought the property for the $312,650 then owed. The borrower said the property was worth $1 million. He sued to set the sale aside, alleging the lender had lulled him with continuing negotiations and an oral promise not to sell without telling him. He said he had tendered the full debt days after the sale. In fact he had no money and no loan commitment, only a hoped-for sale of part of the land and a hoped-for refinancing. Later he asked the court to undo the sale on condition that he pay whatever the court found due.
What the court decided
The lender won on the pleadings. To cancel a voidable trustee’s sale, the borrower must make a valid tender of the debt, and an offer to pay means nothing from someone who cannot perform it. A request that the court set terms was not a tender either. The court noted that otherwise a lender would have no real security at all. The oral promise was unenforceable, and without a tender the remaining claims fell too.