BENJY LAW CORPORATION

Lender Resources · Part V of V

When the borrower sues

A borrower facing foreclosure often sues first. See what a borrower must put on the table to stop or undo a sale, when a lender owes a duty of care, and how a rate problem turned a decade of interest into principal.

6 war storiesCalifornia lawFrom War Stories from the Loan File

Talk to a lawyer: (310) 203-2650

General information about California law, not legal advice. Reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship.

In this part · 6 war stories
  1. 27A hope of refinancing was not a tender
  2. 28The lender foreclosed after the borrower had paid everything he legally owed
  3. 29A borrower in default could still challenge an assignment as void
  4. 30The lender’s appraisal was for the lender
  5. 31A decade of interest became principal payments
  6. 32Exempt from usury did not mean any rate would do
Lender FAQ →

Borrowers in default have lawyers too. The lawsuit usually arrives just before the sale date, asking a court to stop it, or just after, asking a court to undo it. It tends to come with claims that the lender was careless, broke a promise, or charged an unlawful rate.

Many of these claims fail, and the cases in this part show why. Others succeed, usually because of something in the lender’s own file. Know which is which before you answer the complaint.

Stopping or undoing the sale

27Tender rule

A hope of refinancing was not a tender

Karlsen v. American Savings & Loan Assn. (1971) 15 Cal.App.3d 112 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A lender held a trustee’s sale and bought the property for the $312,650 then owed. The borrower said the property was worth $1 million. He sued to set the sale aside, alleging the lender had lulled him with continuing negotiations and an oral promise not to sell without telling him. He said he had tendered the full debt days after the sale. In fact he had no money and no loan commitment, only a hoped-for sale of part of the land and a hoped-for refinancing. Later he asked the court to undo the sale on condition that he pay whatever the court found due.

What the court decided

The lender won on the pleadings. To cancel a voidable trustee’s sale, the borrower must make a valid tender of the debt, and an offer to pay means nothing from someone who cannot perform it. A request that the court set terms was not a tender either. The court noted that otherwise a lender would have no real security at all. The oral promise was unenforceable, and without a tender the remaining claims fell too.

DoWhen a borrower sues over a sale, ask first: where is the money? Demand proof of funds behind any claimed tender.
Don’tDon’t ignore a real tender. A full, unconditional payment of what is owed changes everything, as the next case shows.
28Usury and tender

The lender foreclosed after the borrower had paid everything he legally owed

Winnett v. Roberts (1986) 179 Cal.App.3d 909 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

Private lenders made a $7,000 loan at 40 percent, secured by a deed of trust. The borrower happened to hold a real estate broker’s license. The lenders did not, and no broker arranged the loan. After default and a notice of sale, the borrowers offered in writing to pay the principal plus 10 percent interest. The lenders refused. A court then paused the sale on condition that the borrowers pay the $7,000 principal, which they did. The trial court then ruled the loan exempt and declined to block the sale further. The lenders held the sale and bought the property for $4,415.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal ordered the sale, the trustee’s deed, and the deed of trust cancelled. The loan was usurious, so the lenders were entitled to principal only and no interest at all. Once the principal was paid, there was no debt left to secure and nothing to foreclose. The borrowers were also entitled to their attorney fees under the note’s fee clause.

DoIf a borrower raises usury before a sale, stop and have the loan’s exemption checked. If the principal is tendered on a loan with a rate problem, take it.
Don’tDon’t press a foreclosure to collect interest you may not be entitled to. You can lose the sale, the lien, and the fee fight.

Note: this loan was for personal expenses. Which loans and lenders are exempt from the usury limits is covered in Part I.

29Wrongful foreclosure

A borrower in default could still challenge an assignment as void

Yvanova v. New Century Mortgage Corp. (2016) 62 Cal.4th 919 · California Supreme Court

What happened

According to the complaint, a homeowner’s lender went bankrupt in 2007 and was liquidated in 2008. In 2011 a document was recorded in which that defunct lender purported to assign her deed of trust to a securitized trust, years after the trust’s closing date. The property was then sold at a trustee’s sale. She sued to undo the sale. The trial court dismissed her case, and the Court of Appeal held she could not add a wrongful foreclosure claim: she was not a party to the assignment, so she had no standing to complain about it.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court reversed on that one point. Only the true holder of the beneficial interest, or its agent, may direct a trustee’s sale. A borrower who has lost property to foreclosure may claim that the assignment to the foreclosing party was void, not merely voidable. The court called its ruling narrow. It did not allow suits to block a sale in advance, and it did not decide that this assignment was actually void.

DoBefore you start a foreclosure on a loan you bought, confirm the chain: endorsements on the note, recorded assignments, and the authority of everyone who signed them.
Don’tDon’t create or back-date “clean-up” assignments on the eve of foreclosure without counsel. A void one can hand the borrower a claim.

Note: this was a home-loan case from the securitization era. For a commercial lender the practical point is loan-purchase diligence: you can only foreclose what you can prove you own.

“The lender owed me a duty”

30Duty of care

The lender’s appraisal was for the lender

Nymark v. Heart Federal Savings & Loan Assn. (1991) 231 Cal.App.3d 1089 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A homeowner applied to refinance. The lender had the property appraised for its own underwriting, and the borrower paid the appraisal fee. The report said the roof, foundation, and systems appeared sound. Four years later the county red-tagged the house for construction defects costing more than $50,000 to fix. The borrower stopped paying and sued, claiming the lender had been negligent in the appraisal. The lender cross-complained for judicial foreclosure and moved for summary judgment.

What the court decided

The lender won. As a general rule, a financial institution owes no duty of care to a borrower when its involvement in the loan does not exceed its conventional role as a lender of money. An appraisal done to satisfy the lender that its collateral is adequate is done for the lender’s protection, not the borrower’s. Negligence liability arises only when a lender actively participates in the borrower’s enterprise beyond the usual role of a lender.

DoSay in your application and disclosures that appraisals, inspections, and underwriting are for the lender’s use only and may not be relied on by the borrower.
Don’tDon’t advise the borrower on the deal, vouch for the property or the project, or take control of the borrower’s business decisions.

Also: the California Supreme Court later held that a lender owes no negligence duty to process, review, and respond carefully to a borrower’s loan-modification application, because the economic loss rule bars that claim. Sheen v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. (2022) 12 Cal.5th 905.

Usury as a weapon

31Usury

A decade of interest became principal payments

Hardwick v. Wilcox (2017) 11 Cal.App.5th 975 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

Over ten years an individual lender made a series of loans, secured by commercial properties, at 11 or 12 percent. The notes were extended, rolled over, and combined through fifteen notes and amendments. When the borrower fell behind in 2012, the lender started foreclosure and, on his lawyer’s advice, had the borrower sign a forbearance agreement with a general release. The borrower later sued for usury. The lender argued the release and the statute of limitations barred most of the claim.

What the court decided

The borrower won. Every note in the chain carried a usurious rate, so the interest terms were void and the interest paid over the years was credited against principal. He also recovered $227,235.83 in interest paid during the two years before suit. The release did not help: the forbearance agreement settled no dispute, neither side knew of the usury claim, and reading it as a waiver of usury would violate public policy. Renewing a usurious loan carries the problem forward.

DoConfirm the usury exemption for every loan before you fund, and again before you extend, roll over, or forbear. An extension is a new chance to get it right or wrong.
Don’tDon’t count on a general release in a forbearance agreement to cure a rate problem neither side has identified.
32Unconscionable rate

Exempt from usury did not mean any rate would do

Carboni v. Arrospide (1991) 2 Cal.App.4th 76 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A licensed real estate broker lent $4,000 for three months at 200 percent a year, secured by a fourth deed of trust on a house. Over the next four months he kept advancing money under the same note until the principal reached $99,346, all at 200 percent. By trial the claimed balance was nearly $390,000. The lender’s own loan agreement recited that the borrower had tried and failed to get a loan anywhere else. The lender sued for judicial foreclosure.

What the court decided

Because a licensed broker made the loan and real property secured it, the usury limits did not apply. The courts cut the rate anyway. The rate was about ten times the market rate for similar loans by the lender’s own testimony, and the borrower had no real alternative. That made the interest term unconscionable. The trial court allowed interest at 24 percent instead, and the Court of Appeal affirmed.

DoPrice for risk, but be able to show how the rate compares to the market for similar loans and that the borrower had choices.
Don’tDon’t write into your own documents that the borrower was desperate and had nowhere else to go. That recital was used against the lender.

Note: the court relied in part on evidence that the money was for family medical bills. A negotiated commercial rate between business parties is a much harder target.

MythThe borrower is in default, so the borrower cannot sue us.
RealityDefault does not close the courthouse. A defaulting borrower was allowed to sue over an allegedly void assignment (Yvanova) and to recover usurious interest (Hardwick).
MythThe borrower signed a release in the forbearance agreement, so we’re covered.
RealityA release helps with ordinary disputes. It did not waive a usury claim that neither side knew about and that the agreement did not settle (Hardwick).
MythA borrower can always tie up a sale by filing suit.
RealityTo undo a voidable sale the borrower must make a real tender of the debt, backed by the ability to pay (Karlsen).
MythWe are exempt from usury, so the rate is beyond challenge.
RealityAn exempt rate can still be attacked as unconscionable in an extreme case (Carboni).

FAQ

Borrower lawsuits

Does a lender owe its borrower a duty of care?

Generally no, as long as the lender stays within its conventional role as a lender of money. A lender that actively participates in the borrower’s venture beyond that role can take on a duty.

Law:Nymark v. Heart Federal Savings & Loan Assn. (1991) 231 Cal.App.3d 1089.

What does a borrower have to show to set aside a trustee’s sale?

More than a low price. A minor notice error that caused no harm is not enough. To cancel a voidable sale the borrower ordinarily must tender the debt and be able to pay it. But a sale held after the default was cured, or after the debt was lawfully paid, has been set aside.

Law:Karlsen v. American Savings & Loan Assn. (1971) 15 Cal.App.3d 112; Knapp v. Doherty (2004) 123 Cal.App.4th 76; Bank of America v. La Jolla Group II (2005) 129 Cal.App.4th 706; Winnett v. Roberts (1986) 179 Cal.App.3d 909.

What happens if a court finds our rate usurious?

The interest terms are void. You are entitled to the principal only. Interest already paid is credited against principal, and the borrower may recover interest paid within two years before suing, or seek three times the interest paid within one year before suing. If principal is still unpaid after maturity, you may recover prejudgment interest on it at the legal rate, which was 7 percent for a note secured by a deed of trust.

Law:Hardwick v. Wilcox (2017) 11 Cal.App.5th 975; Soleimany v. Narimanzadeh (2022) 78 Cal.App.5th 915.

The borrower says our loan officer promised an extension. Is that fraud?

It can be pleaded that way. A fraud claim based on a promise requires proof that the promise was made, that the person making it did not intend to perform it at the time, and that the borrower reasonably relied on it and was harmed. Your defense is usually in the file: what was actually said, in writing, and what the signed documents provide.

Law:CACI Nos. 1900, 1902, 1908.

Can a borrower use the “implied covenant of good faith” to change the loan terms?

The implied covenant protects the benefits of the contract the parties actually made. A borrower must show that the lender’s conduct unfairly kept the borrower from receiving those benefits. Enforcing a default the way the documents allow is ordinarily not a breach.

Law:CACI No. 325.

How long does a borrower have to sue?

It depends on the claim. Claims on a written contract: four years. Fraud: three years from discovery of the facts. Recovery of usurious interest: payments made within two years before suit, though a usury offset against principal can reach back through the whole chain of renewed loans.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. §§ 337, subd. (a), 338, subd. (d); Hardwick v. Wilcox (2017) 11 Cal.App.5th 975.

Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.

(310) 203-2650

Statewide California.