A $2,804 setoff cost the bank its deed of trust
Security Pacific National Bank v. Wozab (1990) 51 Cal.3d 991 · California Supreme Court
What happened
A company owed its bank more than $1 million on a credit line. The owners had guaranteed the debt and later gave the bank a deed of trust on their home to secure the guaranties. Worried about a bankruptcy, the bank swept the deposit accounts, including $2,804.82 from the owners’ personal accounts. The owners said the setoff had waived the deed of trust. The bank reconveyed it and sued on the guaranties for the remaining $976,000. The trial court ruled the bank had lost the debt too.
What the court decided
The California Supreme Court held that the setoff broke the security-first rule of Code Civ. Proc. § 726. A lender with real estate security may not help itself to the debtor’s deposit accounts first. The price was the security: the deed of trust was gone. But a divided court refused to wipe out the debt as well, calling that a penalty 300 times the amount of the setoff. The bank could sue as an unsecured creditor.
Note: the court left open what happens when a setoff is inadvertent and promptly returned. If it happens, reverse it immediately and call counsel.